Bending the Third Rail
Because We Should, We Can, We Do
Tuesday, October 10, 2006
Paper Tiger III
Here's yet another article supporting the idea that North Korea is a paper tiger. Robert Kaplan writes a very fine analysis of North Korea and the surrounding military/political situation. As you might guess, it's quite complex ... and the threat isn't what you might think it is:
The threat from north of the DMZ is formidable. North Korea boasts 100,000 well-trained special-operations forces and one of the world’s largest biological and chemical arsenals. It has stockpiles of anthrax, cholera, and plague, as well as eight industrial facilities for producing chemical agents—any of which could be launched at Seoul by the army’s conventional artillery. If the governing infrastructure in Pyongyang were to unravel, the result could be widespread lawlessness (compounded by the guerrilla mentality of the Kim Family Regime’s armed forces), as well as mass migration out of and within North Korea. In short, North Korea’s potential for anarchy is equal to that of Iraq, and the potential for the deployment of weapons of mass destruction—either during or after pre-collapse fighting—is far greater.

For a harbinger of the kind of chaos that looms on the peninsula consider Albania, which was for some years the most anarchic country in post-Communist Eastern Europe, save for war-torn Yugoslavia. On a visit to Albania before the Stalinist regime there finally collapsed, I saw vicious gangs of boys as young as eight harassing people. North Korea is reportedly plagued by the same phenomenon outside of its showcase capital. That may be an indication of what lies ahead. In fact, what terrifies South Koreans more than North Korean missiles is North Korean refugees pouring south. The Chinese, for their part, have nightmare visions of millions of North Korean refugees heading north over the Yalu River into Manchuria.

...

Kim Jong Il’s compulsion to demonstrate his missile prowess is a sign of his weakness [my emphasis]. Contrary to popular perception in the United States, Kim doesn’t stay up at night worrying about what the Americans might do to him; it’s not North Korea’s weakness relative to the United States that preoccupies him. Rather, if he does stay up late worrying, it’s about China. He knows the Chinese have always had a greater interest in North Korea’s geography—with its additional outlets to the sea close to Russia—than they have in the long-term survival of his regime. (Like us, even as they want the regime to survive, the Chinese have plans for the northern half of the Korean peninsula that do not include the “Dear Leader.”) One of Kim’s main goals in so aggressively displaying North Korea’s missile capacity is to compel the United States to deal directly with him, thereby making his otherwise weakening state seem stronger. And the stronger Pyongyang appears to be, the better off it is in its crucial dealings with Beijing, which are what really matter to Kim.
Kaplan goes on to discuss the real threat in the area, an expanded Chinese/Japanese confrontation with a unified Korea somewhere in the mix (which would explain China's reaction to Jong's "test"). The Japanese already have plenty of nuclear material (why do they get to have it?) to build a bomb within months while not having a sophisticated conventional military.

In the medium to long term, Kim Jong Il may be the least of our worries.

If you want to brush up on Asia politics, go read the article. I think you'll conclude that the potential there is as bad or worse than the middle east.