Bending the Third Rail
Because We Should, We Can, We Do
Monday, October 23, 2006
End Game
Billmon has a post up summarizing the activity recently around the Baker/Hamilton Commission and it's upcoming recommendations on Iraq. Short version? It's possible recommendations are nonsense. He then goes on to examine the ideas being floated .... which all fail miserably. He ends with this:
Small wonder then, that the policy "debate" has now crossed the line into complete fantasy -- like a long piece of dialogue pulled from Waiting for Godot. The realists have turned into surrealists. Baker now sounds almost as naive and deluded as Bush.

As a veteran anti-establishmentarian -- no, let's be honest here, I despise the motherfuckers -- I should be enjoying the hell out of all this. And if it weren't for the hundreds of thousands who have died, and the many more who will die as this fiasco goes even further south, I'm sure I would be.
Exactly.

Interestingly at the other end of the writing perspective, William Arkin was also talking about the end game in Iraq:
America will be humbled when we leave Iraq. Let's recognize this is the bitter pill we must swallow now. It ironically will improve our standing in much of the world as we admit that we need the world's help. It will force us to make a reality of our empty pledge to pursue non-military solutions to the challenge of terrorism.

And what of the enemy? Muslim extremists and terrorists will celebrate our defeat, emboldened even more into believing that they can "win" their war, just as they once defeated the Soviet empire in Afghanistan. It is our punishment and the conundrum: They will celebrate, and they may even be momentarily strengthened. But by stepping off the treadmill, we will also remove so much of the inspiration and certainty that fuels our enemies.
Yep. It's over. Accept it. Swallow that yucky medicine, absorb your loses and move on.

Those who were injured or had family who died early in the war had at least some modicum of ability rationalize their losses. As the war continues, the war simply is a meat grinder with no meaning for the loss. And the waiting for the correct "timing" to release a report, or change course after the elections is nothing short of criminal. Like Billmon, I should be feeling a certain amount of joy in the "I told you so-ness" of the situation. But also like Billmon, I simply feel a sense of despair and emptiness about the entire mess.